Justia Non-Profit Corporations Opinion Summaries

by
Illinois enacted a law requiring certain nonprofit organizations that make substantial grants to publicly post aggregated demographic information about their directors and officers, including categories such as race, gender, and sexual orientation. The American Alliance for Equal Rights, representing two member organizations, filed a pre-enforcement challenge, claiming that the statute compelled speech and encouraged discrimination, violating the First and Fourteenth Amendments. The United States also intervened, pressing the Fourteenth Amendment claim under specific statutory authority. Both plaintiffs sought preliminary injunctions to prevent enforcement of the law.The United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois addressed all motions together. It dismissed the Alliance’s claims related to the posting requirement for lack of standing and dismissed the United States’ complaint entirely on the same ground, also denying both preliminary injunction requests. The district court reasoned that the Alliance lacked standing because its members declared they would not provide demographic information, meaning there would be nothing to post. It also found the United States had not shown an injury in fact, as required for standing.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit reviewed the district court’s rulings. The appellate court found that the United States had standing to enforce federal constitutional rights under the Equal Protection Clause, even if a private plaintiff might not. The court also determined that the Alliance had standing because it was likely that at least one member’s officer or director would respond to the demographic survey, triggering the posting requirement. The court further held that using pseudonyms for member organizations did not defeat standing at this stage.The Seventh Circuit reversed the district court’s dismissals, vacated the denial of preliminary injunctions, and remanded for further proceedings. View "United States of America v State of Illinois" on Justia Law

by
A church organization sued its pastor after he withdrew $223,000 from a parish bank account and deposited the funds into his personal account. The pastor asserted that the money was a personal gift from a church member, who had written three $300,000 checks during a church event. One check was made payable to the church, while the other two had blank payee lines and were delivered in sealed envelopes to two pastors. The recipient pastor initially gave his check to the church president, who filled in the church’s name as payee and deposited the check in the parish account. Later, the church member allegedly told the pastor that the check was intended for him personally, prompting the pastor to transfer the funds to his own account.The Circuit Court of the First Judicial Circuit, Davison County, South Dakota, granted summary judgment in favor of the church on its claims for conversion and breach of fiduciary duty and against the pastor on his counterclaims for conversion and fraud. The court found that all money in the parish account belonged to the church or its parish and concluded that a blank check was not sufficient delivery of a gift. The court also awarded prejudgment interest to the church.The Supreme Court of the State of South Dakota reviewed the case de novo. It held that the check delivered to the pastor was not a completed gift under South Dakota law, but this finding alone did not entitle the church to summary judgment. The court determined that genuine disputes of material fact existed regarding the pastor’s fraud claim, specifically whether the church obtained the funds through misrepresentation of the donor’s intent. The Supreme Court reversed the circuit court’s grant of summary judgment on all claims and remanded for further proceedings. It also reversed the award of prejudgment interest. View "Iglesia Pentecostal V. Torres" on Justia Law

by
Two condominium unit owners challenged actions taken by their association, a nonprofit corporation, after it recorded an amended declaration in 2020 that changed allocations of common-area interests and imposed new rental and moorage rules. The owners alleged that the association unlawfully altered their property and rental rights, failed to properly address encroachments, and breached its governing documents. They also sought to compel the association to remeasure unit square footage and reallocate ownership interests under Idaho law.The District Court of the Fourth Judicial District granted summary judgment to the association on the owners’ claims for declaratory relief, slander of title, quiet title, encroachment, and breach of contract, concluding that these were derivative claims barred by the Idaho Nonprofit Corporation Act because the owners lacked sufficient voting power. The court found these claims challenged corporate actions as ultra vires and could only be brought derivatively. The court also determined the owners' demand for remeasurement and reallocation under Idaho Code section 55-1505(1)(c) was a direct claim, but ruled against them because the association’s actions were not shown to be in bad faith.On appeal, the Supreme Court of the State of Idaho affirmed the district court’s summary judgment on the first five claims, holding that the association’s actions could only be challenged derivatively under the Nonprofit Corporation Act, and the owners lacked standing and did not meet statutory requirements. However, the Supreme Court reversed the summary judgment on the claim for remeasurement and reallocation of ownership interests, finding a genuine dispute of material fact as to whether the association acted in bad faith during the 2020 reallocation. The case was remanded for trial on that claim. No costs were awarded on appeal. View "K & L CRYSTAL BEACH, LLC v. THE CRYSTAL BEACH CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION" on Justia Law

by
Two condominium owners installed glass artwork on the terrace wall of their unit in a residential complex governed by a nonprofit association. The association, citing its declaration of restrictive covenants, fined one of the owners for this installation and required removal of the artwork, asserting that prior written consent was required for such exterior modifications. The owners paid the fine under protest and removed the artwork, but then brought suit seeking injunctive and declaratory relief, arguing that the association had waived enforcement through long-term inaction and that they had relied on this acquiescence to their detriment.The County Court of Harrison County granted summary judgment to the association, ruling that the declaration was unambiguous, the association was entitled to enforce it, and that waiver did not apply. The court adopted the association’s proposed findings and did not address pending discovery requests or motions to compel. The owners appealed to the Harrison County Chancery Court, arguing that summary judgment was improper prior to completion of discovery, especially given their equitable claims of waiver, estoppel, and laches.The Supreme Court of Mississippi reviewed the case on interlocutory appeal. The court held that the doctrines of waiver, estoppel, and laches are fact-intensive and generally require full discovery before summary judgment can be considered. The court affirmed the chancery court’s reversal of summary judgment, finding that the county court abused its discretion by granting summary judgment prematurely and foreclosing discovery necessary to resolve factual issues related to the owners’ equitable claims. The case was remanded for further proceedings in the county court. View "Sea Breeze Condominiums & Resort Owners' Association, Inc. v. Lyons" on Justia Law

by
Plaintiffs, who had donated funds to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, alleged that the Church and its investment subsidiary, Ensign Peak Advisors, Inc., fraudulently induced donations by concealing the true use and accumulation of donated funds. They claimed that the Church misrepresented that tithing would be used for charitable and religious purposes, when instead large portions were invested and used for commercial ventures, such as the development of the City Creek Mall. A key event in the case was the publication of a whistleblower report in December 2019, which was widely reported in national and local media and described how the Church managed and concealed a large investment portfolio. The Church publicly responded, and three other lawsuits were filed by different donors based on similar allegations.After actions were filed in several federal district courts, the cases were consolidated in the United States District Court for the District of Utah. Plaintiffs brought claims for breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, fraudulent concealment, fraudulent misrepresentation, and unjust enrichment, seeking to represent a nationwide class of post-1997 donors. The district court dismissed the consolidated complaint with prejudice, ruling that the claims were untimely under Utah’s three-year statute of limitations for fraud. The court found that the widespread news coverage of the whistleblower report meant that plaintiffs, exercising reasonable diligence, should have discovered the alleged fraud more than three years before filing suit.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed the district court’s dismissal. The Tenth Circuit held that the plaintiffs’ claims were time-barred because the whistleblower report and related media coverage provided sufficient public notice to trigger the statute of limitations, and that reasonable diligence would have led to earlier discovery. The court also found no error in the district court’s procedural rulings and denied the request for leave to amend. View "In re: Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints" on Justia Law

by
Several nonprofit organizations and associations that receive federal funding challenged a memorandum issued by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) shortly after President Trump’s return to office in 2025. The memorandum, M-25-13, directed federal agencies to temporarily pause the obligation and disbursement of all federal financial assistance to analyze compliance with recent executive orders. Plaintiffs argued that the memorandum called for a sweeping freeze on virtually all federal funding, which they alleged would have catastrophic consequences for federally funded programs.The United States District Court for the District of Columbia initially responded to plaintiffs’ request for emergency relief by issuing a temporary restraining order, and later a preliminary injunction, barring OMB from implementing the memorandum. The district court found that the memorandum was likely to be arbitrary and capricious and possibly beyond OMB’s statutory authority. The court rejected the government’s argument that the case was moot after OMB rescinded the memorandum, relying in part on statements from the White House Press Secretary and ongoing funding disruptions.The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit reviewed the preliminary injunction. It did not address the merits of the plaintiffs’ legal arguments or the district court’s interpretation of the memorandum. Instead, it concluded that the plaintiffs’ challenge was likely moot because OMB had rescinded the memorandum before the government knew of the lawsuit and had clarified, in guidance issued the day after the memorandum, that a global funding freeze was not intended. The court found that there was no reasonable expectation the government would reissue the challenged action. As a result, the court vacated the preliminary injunction. View "National Council of Nonprofits v. OMB" on Justia Law

by
Between 1976 and 1984, nine plaintiffs allege they were sexually abused by a part-time counselor at the Boys and Girls Club of Hudson County (BGCHC), a New Jersey nonprofit. Following a 2019 amendment to the New Jersey Child Sexual Abuse Act extending the statute of limitations, these plaintiffs brought suit against BGCHC, Boys and Girls Clubs of America (BGCA), and others, claiming damages from the alleged abuse. BGCA, federally chartered in the District of Columbia and headquartered in Georgia, was not directly involved in the alleged abuse but maintained an affiliation with BGCHC through membership requirements, support, professional development opportunities, and brand usage.In the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, BGCA moved to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction. The court found no general jurisdiction over BGCA but allowed for jurisdictional discovery on specific personal jurisdiction. After discovery, a motion judge held that BGCA was subject to specific personal jurisdiction in New Jersey based on its relationship and activities with BGCHC. BGCA appealed, and the Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division, reversed, finding the evidence insufficient to establish that BGCA’s conduct related to the plaintiffs' claims of abuse. The plaintiffs then sought further review.The Supreme Court of New Jersey reviewed the case and affirmed the Appellate Division’s ruling. The Court held that New Jersey courts cannot exercise specific personal jurisdiction over BGCA because the plaintiffs’ claims do not arise out of or relate to any affirmative act by BGCA directed toward New Jersey. The Court clarified that BGCA’s provision of resources, branding, and support to BGCHC did not constitute purposeful availment for the purposes of specific jurisdiction in this context. As a result, the claims against BGCA were dismissed, though proceedings against BGCHC in New Jersey continue. View "E.T. v. The Boys and Girls Club of Hudson County" on Justia Law

by
A sexual assault counselor employed by a nonprofit mental health organization was asked multiple times by her supervisors to disclose the location and information regarding a minor victim, whom law enforcement and county officials were seeking in connection with a probation violation. The counselor refused to provide this information without the victim’s consent, citing the statutory sexual-assault-counselor privilege. Despite her refusal, and after continued pressure, the counselor was ultimately terminated from her position. She then brought claims against her employer under the Minnesota Whistleblower Act and for common-law wrongful discharge, arguing that disclosing the information would have violated the sexual-assault-counselor privilege.The Washington County District Court granted the employer’s motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim, finding that the facts alleged did not support that the requested disclosure would violate the privilege statute. The Minnesota Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the sexual-assault-counselor privilege is limited to disclosures made in the context of a court action or proceeding, or before someone authorized to receive evidence, and that the counselor had not alleged such circumstances.The Supreme Court of Minnesota affirmed the decision of the court of appeals. The court held that the sexual-assault-counselor privilege in Minnesota Statutes section 595.02, subdivision 1(k), applies only in an “action or proceeding, civil or criminal, in court or before any person who has authority to receive evidence.” Because the counselor did not allege she was ordered to disclose information in such a context, her claims under the Minnesota Whistleblower Act and for common-law wrongful discharge failed as a matter of law. The court declined to extend the privilege or recognize a broader common-law claim, emphasizing that any broader confidentiality protections would need to come from the legislature. View "Wredberg vs. Canvas Health, Inc." on Justia Law

by
A religious nonprofit organization sought to purchase a former university campus property after being selected as the winning bidder in a competitive process conducted by a state university system. Following the public announcement of the award, there was significant public opposition to the sale, particularly due to the religious nature of the winning bidder. Two unsuccessful bidders filed administrative protests, raising both procedural and substantive objections, including criticism of the university's decision to sell to a religious organization. The university's designated official initially denied these protests, but upon further internal review, a higher-level administrator determined that a flaw in the bid evaluation process—specifically, the failure to consider cost-saving proposals for existing infrastructure—warranted rescinding the award and restarting the process. In the new round, the property was awarded to a different bidder who scored higher under revised criteria.The original winning bidder, the religious organization, challenged the university's decision in the United States District Court for the District of Maine, alleging violations of the Equal Protection and Free Exercise Clauses of the U.S. Constitution. The district court denied the plaintiff’s motions for a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction, finding that the plaintiff failed to show a likelihood of success on the merits of either claim. The court credited testimony that the university’s decision was motivated by cost-saving considerations rather than religious bias, and found no clear evidence of procedural irregularity or pretext.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit reviewed the denial of the preliminary injunction for abuse of discretion. The Court affirmed the district court’s decision, holding that the lower court applied the correct legal standards and did not clearly err in its factual findings. The Court concluded that the plaintiff failed to demonstrate a likelihood of success on the merits of its constitutional claims. View "Calvary Chapel Belfast v. University of Maine System" on Justia Law

by
The case centers on a lawsuit filed by the Attorney General of Florida against the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and other organizations, alleging that their advocacy for gender-affirming care violated several Florida statutes, including the state's Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act, RICO Act, and antitrust law. The Florida enforcement action targeted AAP's policy statements and legal filings that supported access to gender-affirming care for transgender youth, with the Attorney General seeking significant monetary penalties and organizational restrictions. Although the lawsuit was publicized, there was a three-month delay before the organizations were served.Following the initiation of the Florida state court action, AAP, an Illinois nonprofit, filed a separate suit in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois. AAP claimed that the Florida enforcement proceeding was brought in bad faith to retaliate against its First Amendment–protected advocacy. The district court granted a preliminary injunction to prevent the Florida Attorney General from pursuing the enforcement action against AAP and denied the Attorney General’s motion to dismiss, finding that personal jurisdiction and venue in Illinois were supported, and that the facts suggested the Florida action was brought in bad faith.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit reviewed only whether to stay the district court’s injunction during the expedited appeal. The Seventh Circuit denied the motion for a stay, holding that the Attorney General did not make a strong showing of likely success on the merits or irreparable harm. The court found that the bad-faith exception to Younger abstention applied based on the district court’s factual findings, and that jurisdiction and venue in Illinois were appropriate given the circumstances. The injunction against the Florida enforcement action remains in effect pending appeal. View "American Academy of Pediatrics v Uthmeier" on Justia Law